Demand-Side Tokenomics Evaluation Framework

Tokenomics is a portmanteau of token and economics. Economics is made up of supply, and demand.
Demand-side tokenomics describe the ways a token accrues value through its role in the protocol, rather than through supply-side tactics like low float, or artificial scarcity - accounting tricks used to inflate token price.
Token Dynamics uses a framework with tangible metrics to evaluate protocols on the demand-side of their tokenomics - we call it the Demand-Side Tokenomics Framework.
The Tokenomics Trilemma
At the core of this framework are the principles of tokenomics: protocol utility, value accrual, and economic security which quantify the usefulness, fundamental value, and incentive alignment of a protocol.
These principles form a natural trilemma, as each represents one of three core stakeholders in a protocol.
- Protocol Utility: Users
- Value Accrual: Investors
- Economic Security: Protocol & Creators
Every protocol design decision involves tradeoffs between two of these three.
It is a protocol designer’s role to maximize the aggregate, solving for all three principles to make protocols which are useful, valuable, and secure.
Metrics
To paraphrase management expert Peter Drucker: “only what gets measured gets managed.”
Frameworks without practical applications are useless. We use various quantitative metrics to evaluate (and inform our own) protocol and token designs.
Protocol Utility
Protocol utility is the usefulness of a protocol to distinct user groups, analogous to value creation in a business.
In particular, protocol utility is measured for essential users - i.e. those who value the protocol for what it does, rather than its participatory incentives.
Essential users (e.g. borrowers in Aave) are different from mercenary users (e.g. liquidators), who also serve a role, but are more purely financially motivated.
This should be axiomatic - Aave’s utility is better measured as the demand for borrowing; liquidations are incidental, not direct drivers of protocol growth.
Unique Value Propositions
It is maximized by solving large problems and leveraging one or more of blockchains’ unique value propositions:
- Configurable privacy
- Asset programmability
- Censorship-resistance
Total Addressable Market (TAM)
Protocol utility is measured by total addressable market (TAM). TAM is somewhat subjective, but possible to infer.
In our valuation models, it is an adjustable assumption. Good proxies come from the question: “how much revenue do incumbent solutions generate?”
In zero-to-one solutions, such as Uniswap circa 2018, a good question might be “how large could this market become?”
Value Accrual
Tokens accrue fundamental value, leading to price floors according to their role in a protocol. These ways a token is used in a protocol are called tokenomic mechanisms, and their degree of value accrual is called tokenomic leverage.
TradFi Analogs
Tokenomic mechanisms tend to accrue value to tokens analogously to three asset classes in traditional finance: equities, currencies, and commodities.
SushiSwap’s dividends and MakerDAO’s buyback-and-burn system are both equity-like tokenomic mechanisms.
ETH’s use as gas in the blockspace economy, and XMR’s use for private remittances are currency-like tokenomic mechanisms; the assets can be valued accordingly.
Commodity-like tokenomic mechanisms are rare, since commodities represent arbitrageable value. In practice, there are very few protocols which operate according to the principle of “one token, one use.” Most tokens which are touted as commodities are actually currencies in very narrow economies (see ETH).
A true commodity-like token would be something like a Pac-Man token: one token, one play. This was the original vision for utility tokens, but the business model proved indefensible.
Tokenomic Leverage
Tokens accrue different amounts of value depending on their roles in a protocol. The degree to which a token or mechanism accrues value is called tokenomic leverage.
It is calculated as value accrued divided by value addressed.
For example, a token which receives $10m (say, in fees) from a protocol facilitating $1B of value has a tokenomic leverage of $10m/$1B = 0.01.
Tradeoffs
Protocol utility and value accrual are at odds when a protocol monetizes directly, e.g. through fees.
This makes intuitive sense, as users and investors effectively split the value created by a protocol.
Uniswap provides a poignant example of the tradeoff - UNI token holders can only turn on the fee switch through governance by diverting value to themselves - the investors - from one of two user groups: UNI traders, or LPs.
Tradeoffs between protocol utility and value accrual - i.e. users and investors - can be avoided if a protocol monetizes indirectly, at the cost of economic security.
The token can be introduced in protocol operations in ways which cause it to accrue value, but make the protocol in some way dependent on token price.
Economic Security
Economic security is the alignment of incentives in a protocol such that no user can act in a way that compromises the protocol itself.
Whereas technical security is a lack of bugs in a protocol’s code, economic security is a lack of bugs in its incentives.
Economic Security Assessment
Key metrics in economic security include cryptoeconomic authority and attack profitability, found in Token Dynamics’s economic audit reports.
At a high level, economic security is measured similarly to technical security, with the number of bugs of different severities found in an economic audit.
Token Dynamics’s economic audits share classification conventions with most technical audits of low, medium, high, and critical severity vulnerabilities.
Conclusion
Token Dynamics’s Demand-Side Tokenomics Evaluation Framework assesses these factors: protocol utility, value accrual, and economic security, as well as the supply-side tokenomics of a protocol, to the degree they affect these.
These evaluations are superficial - a light version of each of Token Dynamics’s services. These include:
- Protocol design, aligning participant incentives with what users need from the protocol
- Economic audits, identifying where those incentives expose users or the protocol to losses
- Financial valuation & tokenomic models, documenting value accrual
- Pitch decks & whitepapers, explaining the design
Tokenomics evaluations score protocols’ tokenomics on these principles to provide insight into where they might be able to improve.